23 April 2019 at 20:27 #3802
Hi Stefania! Very nice to hear from you, and what a Topic you have introduced!
First of all, the article presents this interesting analogy: in fact both of these two industries have defined new standards but in my opinion data is turning out to be even more important with respect to oil. In these past recent years the abuse of personal data by tech giants draw a lot of attention and it let no shortage of criticism from the public. It is clear that a debate on data would touch many different topics and would need a lot of time to address all of them properly but I’ll try to first take a closer look to what we are talking about.
Oil is a scarce resource and it exist in a limited amount in nature. It is used in a vast number of industries, for medicines, plastics, fertilizers and more importantly to generate power. Of course it is and has been fundamental for the automotive industry throughout the 20th century until now.
Data in the other hand is not scarce, is limitless and most importantly it only increases with time. While oil is a resource that we use data is instead some kind of asset that represents us very intimately: it is not something we just use but rather something we are. So from here it is clear why lots of concerns have been raised and why companies like google, having the tech and the expertise, are considered dangerous to some extent. They can collect and analyze massive amounts of data and then perform big data analysis which is, as you already said, an incredible tool not only for predicting trends but potentially also for influencing people. Of course this can be an extremely dangerous problem that requires to be addressed. In addiction to this I found this recent survey of PWC suggesting data as the “most valuable” a company would like to harvest in 2019 (here it is the link).
Of course as @michelebaldo said it is important that companies of this size help the global community by paying the right amount of taxes, while so far there have been many occasions proving this to be not true, for instance with Google exploiting tax loopholes in Ireland (https://www.independent.ie/business/technology/news/google-ireland-pays-171m-tax-as-sales-hit-record-32bn-37560617.html). I agree with you when you say that data has to be taxed: it is necessary to find a way to transfer the generated wealth back to the community. But all these problems are probably enhanced by the fact that this new era of digital data science is still relatively new and still regulations have to fully adapt to these new standards. This in my opinion is a pattern that shows up every time some new technology becomes widespread and I think in the end will be the same also this time. It is still possible that new technologies will come into play: in this case maybe blockchain will be an opportunity, creating some sort of distributed digital trust that will enable users to get paid every time their data will be harvested.
As regards taxes on automation and robots I would consider this as a topic on its own, different from data, but for sure a very significant one. Of course we have to start to think about what we will do once the vast majority of manufacturing jobs will be taken by robots. At this day it is not possible to have a solution but as time goes by it will continue to grow bigger, I personally think that some new education patterns will be developed but I can’t really imagine more at the moment.
Regarding oil vs data I think it could be interesting to compare the companies involved and maybe draw some conclusions about the question pose in the article: do we need this dominance to be broken apart? First of all Standard Oil’s size at the time was really concerning for the US congress and it didn’t really have competition any more. Today of course we have this really big tech firms but they are not a single company and we have many occasion where they compete against each other, for instance Google Circles vs Facebook, Google search engine vs Bing, Alexa vs Google Assistant but also many others. Moreover we have to remember that a reshuffle is still possible, new companies can join the competition coming with new technologies in an unpredictable manner: for instance after the splitting of Standard Oil in 1911 we have seen many new countries discovering massive oil fields and become the world leaders in oil extraction.
The last topic I would like to touch regards the Chinese counterparts of this tech firms. Even if sometimes we are not pleased with our laws and regulations and tend to consider them a little restricting we should take a look to what happens in a country where the legislation is much less severe. Last week I found myself reading this article. I think it remarks the huge risks we undertake when a centralized autority can use data in this way and again it reminds of the importance of the topic.
23 April 2019 at 20:55 #3804
- This reply was modified 7 months, 2 weeks ago by Andrea Zuccotto.
Hi Marcus! I saw that we ended up talking about a similar topic.
Well, of course these technologies would have some benefits on our society but on the other hand I can’t avoid thinking about the risks. In general centralized systems like China tend to be more efficient with respect to decentralized and distributed ones, let’s consider the effectiveness and the speed of the chinese goverments to create an EV legislation out of nowhere while here in Italy we have very long iters even for the less important laws, but this centrlized system works only if the systems is deeply trusted by everybody, and this in general is not true, and recalling the article I suggested in the previous post it is really easy to see why. So maybe one possible solution could be to create some sort of decentralized digital database where some information obtained about every one of us can be accessible but firmly restricting the access to our identity. Maybe in the future something similar will be done with some blockchain based technology. Let’s think for instance to what happens with blockchain adresses: they are public, so evreryone knows how much bitcoins or other currencies are associated to them, while the identity of the owner is unknown.
Let me know what you think!26 April 2019 at 14:38 #3807
Great thoughts @andreazuccotto , I particularly liked the discussion about oil and data.
Recordings are important to improve voice assistants, but companies should be clear with the users about how their data are utilized and if a user choose to don’t allow recording to be sent to the company, the company have to provide an option in privacy settings that allow the user to do it.
I think the solution could be the one proposed by Google. As the article say: “At Google, some reviewers can access some audio snippets from its Assistant to help train and improve the product, but it’s not associated with any personally identifiable information and the audio is distorted, the company says.”
In conclusion users should be able to have full control on their data (according to GDPR). Thus, privacy settings must allow the user to change at any time their options and be able to have really control on which data are recorded and which aren’t. Moreover all recordings have to be collected in complete anonymity.Stefania TibilettiParticipant@stefaniatibiletti27 April 2019 at 14:21 #3808
Thank you for sharing your thoughts.
Here I have the last two articles:
Do not forget that you can add information from other sources, also changing the topic and asking questions to your colleagues.
Deadline: April 30th at midnight (04/30/2019 – 12am CEST)
You have time until midnight on Tuesday 30th April to send me your resume via email ( email@example.com ) in order to confirm your willingness to participate at the Tour. The resume must be in American format – 1 page – and attached you have a template that might help you. If you have questions, please feel free to contact me.
Have a nice weekend.
28 April 2019 at 20:07 #3810
- This reply was modified 7 months, 2 weeks ago by Stefania Tibiletti.
Hi Stefania, thanks for introducing me to the GDPR, I didn’t really know it before, and also thank you @michelebaldo, I’m happy you enjoyed my oil vs data comparison!
I read the articles you proposed, and I think they raise some interesting warnings: first of all with Amazon Echo. Well, I would being annoyed if I knew my voice have been recorded without my consent, while in the article it reported that “people who (deny the consent) opt out of that program might still have their recordings analyzed by hand over the regular course of the review process”. I personally can’t find the reason why Amazon would do that, maybe is just in the case they run out of data provided with consent but I still consider that a little too undue. Of course, as again @michelebaldo pointed out, there is nothing wrong in training an algorithm but companies must be told to be crystal clear about their data policies and what they do with the conversations they harvest. Maybe most of the user still are not sensible enough on this kind of issues but this could also help us understand the growing distrust with respect to said companies, just as @michelebaldo and @marcusvukoejvic discussed in some previous posts.
But then there is something else to consider: now we have the tools to catch some useful information that can be used to improve safety or maybe even to prevent crimes: as the article says some workers for example believed to have picked up a sexual assault, or also a kid looking for help. With Echo it could be easier to get this people some help if only the assistant could provide real time assistance. The big question in my opinion is this one: “Is it correct to use this data for prevention or safety and if the answer is yes, up to what extent?”. This is indeed a really tough one to be answered, but I collected some material to help contextualizing the topic. For example I saw this video about some foreigners working in Shenzen: one of them was recognized with some security camera walking jaywalking a street crossing and was fined on its WeChat some instants later, having its money directly taken from his balance without even an authorization. I really suggest you to see the video and try to imagine these kind of things happening to us, let me know what you think. Of course it would also have some benefits, for instance also in Shenzen face recognition has almost cleared the risked of home invasions that were very common back in the day. In this case I think the European GDPR is here exactly to create laws to protect the most vulnerable subjects and avoid situations that are at the moment taking place in some other countries, moreover it helps creating a right environment for European companies by securing data certification and quality, as it is explained in this interesting article I found https://www.agendadigitale.eu/sicurezza/perche-il-gdpr-servira-alle-aziende-a-crescere-innovare/ .
Another really interesting article related to the previous and also to the GDPR and data is about 5G and Huawei: in this article the main question is: “If the Chinese Government asks Huawei to give data coming from European countries harvested with 5G infrastructures, can they refuse to do that? ”. Well, surprisingly the Chinese invoked for a new GDPR regulation in order to cancel out these warnings coming from the US: in my opinion this gives even more credit to the european regulations, making them the standard to built this new EU-China cooperation. I hope I was clear with my discussion, let me know your thoughts about that!30 April 2019 at 23:39 #3818
I absolutely agree with you @andreazuccotto : GDPR should be the new standard and it should be adopted not only by Europe but also by other countries. In particular by USA and China where most of tech companies are and where most of the technology is assembled. Europe is giving a great example and human rights are our priority.
Privacy and security are not an extra feature of a digital service, but data protection and ownership of ourselves data should be given for granted in any digital product and service.Stefania TibilettiParticipant@stefaniatibiletti2 May 2019 at 9:05 #3819
Here we are!
The eligibility for the Silicon Valley Study Tour 2018
- Andrea Zuccotto
- Marcus Vukojevic
- Michele Baldo
For more info about the possibility to have a sponsorship from the University, please refer to Prof. Alessandro Rossi.
If you have questions, do not hesitate to contact me!
Have a nice week
15 September 2019 at 21:51 #11456
- This reply was modified 7 months, 1 week ago by Stefania Tibiletti.
Here we are after the tour. The experience was amazing and wonderful. It was just one week, but we learnt as much as an entire lifetime, we met incredible people and we saw incredible places. Thank you very much for the opportunity. Hope to see you all soon in Silicon Valley again!9 October 2019 at 11:07 #11461
August 2019, “Silicon Valley Study Tour, a memorable experience where people grow and open their mind.” This is my best way to describe the past two weeks in the Bay Area of California, a place where everything seems possible. Travelling and discover new places, different cultures and way of thinking, meeting new people is always an experience where people grow and learn something. The opportunity of SVST is this and more. We flew directly in the heart of the future and innovation, where everything you see online is built. There we met incredible people, many Italians who choose to seek in that place their future, trying to build the next big thing or just contribute in the success of a big corp. We listened to their stories, their lives experience, their dreams, the journeys that took them there and much more. We met amazing people, optimist about the future and with incredible passion for what they were doing. It was just a week but we learned as much as a year.
The mindset in the valley is completely different from our and so it is the way of perceiving the world. As you can guess from the introduction above you can definitely feel it every time you step into a company. There is energy, everything is thriving. Moreover everything is huge in those big companies. Google and Facebook bought miles and miles of land, so much land that they are building their cities and they are giving even names at streets. Facebook has even a garden with trees, trails and grasslands on the roof of a building (a huge building). Apple has a big garden inside the “spaceship” a gigantic rounded building looking like a huge doughnut of 1.6 km in circumference. Free food and gym access is the norm. At Facebook we tried some Indonesian cuisine, some good beef steaks and we went in an Italian-like pastry shop where we tried a gelato, all for free. To move from a building to another in the campus of those big companies you definitely need to use the company bikes or small buses, otherwise it takes ages.
We visited also the famous Stanford and Berkeley universities. The university concept is completely different compared to the Italian university one. One big campus where all student study, research and live. It’s a small city with palm trees along the sunny roads and anything you need, from classrooms and labs to gyms and fast foods. Obviously all of that comes also with an onerous tuition, far away form the “free education” that we have here in Europe.
Precisely speaking of expenses, costs for living in the valley are insanely high. All that glitters is not gold, everything has it’s downsides. Everything is far too expensive there. For example in San Francisco, households earning $117,000 qualify as ‘low income’. The social gap between the rich and the poor it’s insanely wide and literally thousands of homeless people live on the streets of the city. They are definitely living in a kind of economic bubble that will blow soon or later. And last but not least, as a good Italian would say, the food in America is awful or too expensive (out of Facebook or Google of course) and they have a serious problem of obesity. Don’t forget that they don’t have a public healthcare system. Many families “cannot afford to get sick” and usually many of them avoid going to the doctor to save money. These facts remind us how lucky we are here in Europe and in Italy where the quality of life (and the Italian food) is much higher quality than the American standard. Also about education and research we do pretty well even with the limited amount of money that our venture provide. But we can also learn a lot from the Silicon Valley. In particular the mindset of those people who think everything is possible and of those who built empires from nothing, moving huge ventures and giving birth to insane new technology.
All this was definitely super inspiring not only to appreciate better what we have here in Italy and in Europe, but also to see what we can improve and bring back from the “American dream mindset”, which was the spark to the growth of incredible startups, companies and ventures.
So define your goals and your dreams and define a clear plan to reach them. Because there’s always a way. And then just do it, don’t wait. Don’t fear failing. If you fall never mind, it’s all good experience, just stand up and start running again towards your goals.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.